Voices

Do Not Disturb

Students, teachers, and administrators weigh in on the new focus on the phone policy

At the beginning of the 2024 school year, the school implemented a new phone rule. This rule led to the “Bell to bell, no cell” signs that students still see today, and some teachers added phone caddies or storage units to their classrooms.

However, as the 2026-2027 school year rolled around, this phone policy has taken a turn–for better or for worse. Phone storage units are now required in every classroom, and students are mandated to place their phones in the caddies upon entry into the classroom. This has been a difficult change for many and has raised questions regarding the purpose behind these alterations.

“A primary reason was consistency for kids in terms of expectations for when you guys walk into the classroom,” Principal Mark Mischke said.

Some students find these new rigid rules to be challenging; however, this change isn’t so dramatic for some.

“Honestly, I have never been one to be super distracted by having my phone–in school at least–but at the middle school you had to keep your phone in your lockers all day so this change to the phone policy isn’t very ‘new’ to me,” Logan Zelinski ‘30 said.

Many of the incoming freshmen are used to the strict phone policy at BCMS. But the upperclassmen who have gotten used to phone usage during the school day may be questioning why these updates are necessary.

“We want to maximize the ability for you to have connections with the experience in the classroom, and I really believe that phones out of the way help,” Mischke said.

Some students agree with this.

“Even though many oppose this new change, it has impacted our school in a good way,” Trinity Poepke ‘29 said. “I haven’t seen many with their phones out and productivity and physical/verbal communication has increased.”

Teachers have also taken attention to this shift in connections.

“I’ve noticed that students are much more social with both their peers and their teachers this year,“ Mathematics Teacher Joel Peterson said. “In the past, when they had time to work independently or in groups, a lot of students would sit quietly, doom scroll, or text friends. With phones put away, students are talking more, interacting with each other, and building some of those important social skills that seem to have been lost or impacted by social media.

Many teachers and students agree that it is easier to focus and interact with others with their phones up in the caddies, but there are some drawbacks from this initial increase in focus.

“Some days I am waiting for a big text or waiting on something important and it may cause me to be stressed out if I’m unable to check it,” Mack McCluskey ‘28 said.

So, while some students are content with leaving their phones in the storage units, others face difficulty when waiting for significant messages.

Because of this, many students turn to their laptops to replace their phones. When looking around a classroom, there is typically at least one student with their laptop open, paying little attention to the current lesson being taught, and teachers are very aware of this loophole.

“Teachers are very aware of students just shifting from their phones to computers to access their social media and games, so I think the engagement works best with a combo of the phone policy and physical materials,” Social Studies Teacher Dwight Monson said.

While tightening the policies on cellular devices may work momentarily, more action may be necessary to truly increase student engagement and minimize student distraction.

Students report that the new policy helps them stay focused and connected in class, but the urge to check their devices can become overwhelming at times and take away from their learning. These new rules are a part of a bigger, nationwide act against cell phone usage and its impact on human connection.

Photos by Brynna Murray.
Show More

Livia Sanders

Hello! My name is Via and I am apart of the Hoofprint's social media team and Herdcast.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button